Should We Buy A Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic?

The number of new guns purchased in the United States has reached an all-time high. Recent gun sales in 2022 have been increasing rapidly. It's improbable that large game hunting and target shooting have suddenly become popular enough to increase the number of background checks performed throughout the country.

It's a safe guess that most new gun purchases are for self-defense and that many individuals choose handguns as their first weapons. Perhaps millions of Americans are suddenly confronted with an old shooter's favorite argument: Revolvers or semiautomatics are better for self-defense.

Should We Buy A Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic

Semiautomatics Vs. Revolvers:

When the first semiautomatic handguns entered the market, they were no match for the dependability of a revolver. They weren't user-friendly and prone to jamming, making the revolver the preferable option in nearly every situation.

However, as the engineering and technology underlying the automated loaders that drive semiautomatic handguns evolved, the benefits of utilizing a revolver instead of a semi-auto began to fade. Today, the argument isn't whether semi-autos are superior to revolvers but if revolvers are even relevant.

Semi-autos are superior from a mechanical aspect. They experience significantly less recoil, and they have easy-to-modify triggers. The sights are more significant and straightforward, particularly for those new to guns. Most critically, semiautomatics are now among the most dependable weapons available.

Semi-autos also have much more ammunition capacity than equivalent revolvers. Semi-autos offer numerous distinct benefits, whether you're interested in home defense or simply shooting for pleasure. What was formerly prone to failure after a malfunction has recently been perfected.

Revolver Pros:

Easy To Troubleshoot Malfunctions:

If you purchase quality guns and ammunition, firearm malfunctions are common nowadays. They still occur and utilizing a revolver to solve the situation is frequently significantly simpler when they occur. In the instance of faulty ammo, merely firing the trigger again may often be the difference between life and death.

Resilient To Harsh Conditions:

Most people feel revolvers operate better in harsh conditions, such as those with a lot of dirt and dust than pistols. It is due to the simplicity of revolver designs, which lack many of the microscopic components seen in current semiautomatic weapons.

Simple To Use:

Most current revolvers are double-action, which means you pull the trigger to cock the hammer before pushing it again to discharge the weapon. To fire a revolver, you must know how to load it and squeeze the trigger. Their simplicity may also be beneficial in high-pressure self-defense scenarios since it reduces the number of stages that might go wrong.

Stopping Power:

Revolvers are typically chambered in large handgun calibers, such as.357 Magnum, .44 Magnum, and bigger. These large-caliber bullets have exceptional stopping ability not just against people but also against huge wildlife.

While this may boost stopping power, it has several drawbacks, which will be discussed in the following section. It's also worth noting that, although revolvers may be found in some of the biggest calibers, they can also be found in calibers as tiny as.22 LR.

Should We Buy A Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic

 Safer Trigger:

It is an example of something that many people consider a negative but may also be seen as a benefit for revolvers. Because of their larger trigger pulls, it is significantly less probable that you may accidentally fire a revolver.

For example, when you have your finger on the trigger in a high-pressure circumstance, it is unlikely that you will accidentally fire it. Many people feel more secure in their ability to unholster revolvers since accidental trigger pulls are less dangerous.

Internal Hammer Revolvers Won't Get Caught On Cloth:

In a self-defense scenario, if you're concealed carrying, your pistol may get entangled in your shirt while unholstering. It might cause your exposed-hammer revolver or semiautomatic handgun to fail to fire after the first shot. In such a case, a revolver with an internal hammer should be OK.

Revolver Cons:

Low Capacity:

The main disadvantage of "six shooters" is their limited capacity. Revolver cylinders typically hold six cartridges; however, 5- and 7-round abilities are also viral (more so 5-round capacities).

While the larger caliber bullets often employed in revolvers may be more effective when hitting your target, you'd better make sure you hit it with your restricted number of rounds. This issue becomes significantly more problematic when confronted with several assailants in self-defense.

Slower To Reload:

Most people, revolver enthusiasts may object. Still, we are convinced that revolvers are much slower to reload, even with speed loaders. Of course, some extraordinary individuals can reload revolvers quite rapidly. Still, in a high-pressure scenario, we'd feel much more confident reloading a semi-auto handgun.

Should We Buy A Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic


While many contemporary handguns are constructed of lightweight materials such as plastics, most revolvers are made of steel. It enables them to handle the larger calibers in which they are usually chambered while also reducing the perceived recoil of these calibers. The disadvantage is that a revolver may be less comfortable to carry.


Because of the cylinders on revolvers, they are often more comprehensive than other handguns. Again, this may make them more challenging to hide and less comfortable to carry.

Longer, Heavy Trigger Pull:

The trigger pull of a double-action handgun is longer and heavier than that of a standard semiautomatic pistol. It makes it more difficult for many shooters to fire quickly and accurately, particularly when firing several bullets.

Semi-Auto Pistol Pros:

High Capacity:

Semiautomatic pistols have a significant advantage over revolvers due to their more prominent magazines.

Concealed carry and home defense pistols often feature a magazine capacity of 10 rounds, which is more than enough for most potential self-defense situations. For example, the usual magazine capacity of the Glock 19 is 15 bullets.

Faster Reloads:

Assuming they're somewhat comfortable with a particular handgun, the ordinary individual should be able to reload a semi-auto pistol considerably more rapidly than a revolver. It is usually advisable to spend time training with both kinds of pistols (which can be done with an empty magazine).


Polymer-framed pistols, made famous by Glock, are very lightweight and may significantly improve their comfort with concealed carry. The disadvantage of light pistols is that their lightweight construction results in increased perceived recoil. However, recoil with standard handgun calibers should not be a significant issue for most shooters.

Should We Buy A Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic

Easier To Shoot:

You may assume we meant revolvers were simpler to shoot, but they are just easier to learn how to use. Modern semiautomatic pistols have an edge in terms of accurate, practical shooting. It is due to many variables, including:

  • Shorter, Lighter Triggers:

Many new semiautomatic pistols have great triggers that need minimal power to fire over a short distance. It not only helps with speed but also with accuracy, particularly when firing many rapid bullets.

  • Smaller Calibers:

Calibers under.45 ACP and.40 S&W are the most common self-defense handguns. These cartridges have much less recoil than several popular revolver calibers.

  • Ergonomic:

Pistol manufacturers have spent much time to make them as comfortable and well-fitting in your hand as possible.

  • Highly Customizable:

Because Glock pistols are so popular now, almost unlimited alternatives for aftermarket components exist. It enables you to locate and build the ideal handgun for yourself.

Semi-Auto Pistol Cons:

Greater Chance Of Failing:

We don't want this remark to be misinterpreted since contemporary pistols are dependable. Still, they have more components, meaning more things that may fail. Some individuals choose to use a revolver for self-defense instead of a handgun.

Less Stopping Power:

Because semiautomatic handguns are often chambered in smaller caliber rounds than revolvers, less energy is delivered to the intended target. It may reduce your chances of incapacitating your target with the same amount of on-target bullets.

More Complicated To Use:

After completing some study and spending some time at the range, I all handguns are extremely easy to use. Using a handgun is undoubtedly less intuitive.

So Which Is Better, Revolver Or a Semi-Automatic?

Finally, it is up to you to make your own decision. We've written out the pros and cons of pistols versus revolvers, which should help you decide which features are most essential to you in a weapon.

We prefer semiautomatic pistols over revolvers because we believe it is critical to have enough bullets to defend oneself against any severe attack. It, in our opinion, outweighs what We believe to be a slight difference in dependability.

Suppose we searched for a handgun to hunt or defend ourselves against large wildlife. In that case, we'd go for a larger caliber revolver. Whatever pistol you pick, it is essential to get familiar with it and learn how to fire it correctly.